(13.2) Consider a student who is disruptively talking to a neighbor while you are teaching. Develop and list a full continuum of responses for dealing with the unproductive learning behavior.
Unfortunately, there will be many times in which a student or students will disrupt class by talking or any other undesired behavior. This is natural because no student can be perfect, and there will be times when behaviors are not always up to par. However, teachers must be consistent in their responses to these disruptive behaviors in order to decrease the likelihood of these behaviors occurring. The textbook lists a few suggestions on dealing with disruptive behaviors. The first step I would take would be to cue the student. At the first instance of this student chatting to her neighbor, I would not consider stopping the lesson to address this student. I would simply pause for a brief moment and give her a stern look that clearly emphasizes my dislike for her talking during my teaching. Sometimes, a stern look or another brief cue may not work to cease the behaviors. Therefore, if the talking continued even after I gave her a cue, I would catch up to her privately, and discuss the problem with her briefly. I would state that she needed to pay attention, and that her excessive talking is disruptive to her peers' learning. This step might not work, so the next step I would take would be to teach a self-regulation strategy. There are many different strategies that can be used for a student who talks during the teacher's instruction. She can create a tally sheet that marks each time that she speaks while another person is speaking. She would need to mark twice for each time that she speaks when the teacher is speaking, and subsequently interrupts her neighbors from hearing instructions. This would get her to realize what she is doing and how it is negatively impacting her peers. In order to positively reinforce her, every time that she does not speak while someone is talking she can reward herself by adding a tally mark to another list. She and the teacher can work on thinking of activities to plan for her if she reaches a certain ratio on her two sheets (20:5; 20 being the amount of times she does not speak when someone else is speaking and 5 being the times she does). Sometimes this method may not work either, or it may work for only a shortened amount of time. This would be when I would need to go to the next measure and confer with her parents. The first step with this would be to simply call her parents and let them know that she is having problems with staying quiet when others are speaking. If her behavior continued even after doing this, I would have to call her parents in for a conference and discuss preventive measures with them that we all feel would work best in dealing with this problem. Some of the resulting consequences might also need to be reflective at home as well.